Is root canal better than extraction?

Facing severe tooth pain or damage can be deeply concerning, leaving many patients wondering whether a root canal or extraction is the better choice. At Silver Oaks Dental Clinic, with over two decades of experience in advanced endodontic treatments, we understand that this decision significantly impacts your long-term oral health and wellbeing. The choice between preserving your natural tooth with root canal therapy or removing it entirely depends on various factors, including the extent of damage, your overall dental health and individual circumstances. Understanding both procedures can help you make an informed decision about your dental care.

Root Canal treatment

Is a root canal or tooth extraction better? Find out here.

Understanding Root Canal Treatment

A root canal, also known as endodontic therapy, is a sophisticated dental procedure designed to save a tooth when its inner soft tissue (the pulp) becomes inflamed or infected. This inflammation typically occurs due to deep decay, repeated dental procedures, or trauma such as cracks or chips. The pulp contains vital nerves and blood vessels, and when damaged, it can cause excruciating pain and potentially lead to dangerous abscesses if left untreated.

During root canal treatment, our skilled endodontists carefully remove the infected or damaged pulp, meticulously clean and disinfect the interior of the tooth including all root canals, then fill and seal the space with biocompatible materials to prevent future infection. The tooth is typically restored with a filling or crown to ensure proper function and protection.

Key Advantages of Root Canal Therapy

Preserves Your Natural Tooth Structure Maintaining your original tooth is always the gold standard in dentistry. Your natural teeth are irreplaceable, and root canal treatment allows you to keep them functioning normally for potentially decades.

Provides Effective Pain Relief Modern root canal techniques utilise advanced anaesthesia and pain management protocols, making the procedure comfortable and virtually painless. Many patients report that the treatment feels no different from having a routine filling.

Prevents Bone Loss and Structural Changes Unlike extraction, root canal therapy preserves the tooth root, which continues to stimulate the surrounding jawbone, preventing the bone deterioration that commonly occurs with missing teeth.

Maintains Proper Bite Alignment Keeping your natural tooth prevents adjacent teeth from shifting into empty spaces, which can cause bite problems and require additional orthodontic treatment.

Offers Long-term Cost Effectiveness While the initial investment may seem substantial, root canal treatment often proves more economical than extraction followed by tooth replacement options such as implants or bridges.

When Root Canal Treatment May Not Be Suitable

Despite its many benefits, root canal therapy isn’t always the optimal choice. Some situations where extraction might be necessary include:

  • Severe structural damage that compromises the tooth’s integrity
  • Extensive decay below the gumline that cannot be properly restored
  • Vertical root fractures that cannot be repaired
  • Insufficient bone support due to advanced periodontal disease

Understanding Tooth Extraction

Tooth extraction involves the complete removal of a tooth from its socket. This procedure becomes necessary when a tooth is damaged beyond repair or poses a risk to your overall oral health. At Silver Oaks Dental Clinic, we perform both simple and surgical extractions using the latest techniques to ensure patient comfort and optimal healing.

The extraction process begins with thorough numbing of the area. Simple extractions involve loosening and removing the tooth, whilst surgical extractions may be required for teeth that are broken at the gumline or impacted.

Comparing Root Canal vs Extraction: The Evidence

Research from multiple clinical studies shows that root canal treatment has success rates ranging from 79.9% to 93% depending on various factors, with long-term studies demonstrating that many treated teeth can last decades with proper care. A comprehensive long-term study published in Clinical Oral Investigations found 10-year survival rates of 97% for root canal-treated teeth. However, the decision between root canal therapy and extraction should always be individualised based on your specific circumstances.

Root Canal Benefits:

  • Preserves natural tooth function
  • Maintains jawbone integrity
  • Prevents adjacent tooth movement
  • Often more cost-effective long-term
  • High success rate with proper aftercare

Extraction Considerations:

  • Immediate problem resolution
  • Lower initial cost
  • May be the only option for severely damaged teeth
  • Requires replacement planning for optimal function

Making the Right Choice for Your Oral Health

At Silver Oaks Dental Clinic, our experienced team conducts comprehensive evaluations to determine the most appropriate treatment for each patient. We consider factors such as:

  • Extent of tooth damage or decay
  • Your overall oral health status
  • Long-term prognosis and maintenance requirements
  • Personal preferences and lifestyle factors
  • Financial considerations and treatment timeline

Our commitment to using advanced diagnostic technology, including digital X-rays and 3D imaging, ensures accurate assessment and optimal treatment planning for every root canal case.

Quick watch! Dr Craig explains whether a root canal or tooth extraction is better. Watch the short video here.

Prevention: Your Best Defence

The most effective approach to avoiding both root canal treatment and extraction is maintaining excellent oral hygiene and regular dental care. This includes:

  • Attending routine check-ups and cleanings every six months
  • Practising thorough daily brushing and flossing
  • Limiting consumption of sugary and acidic foods and beverages
  • Addressing dental concerns promptly before they become serious
  • Using protective mouthguards during sports activities
  • Avoiding habits that can damage teeth, such as ice chewing or using teeth as tools

Expert Root Canal Treatment at Silver Oaks Dental Clinic

With over 20 years of experience in advanced dental care, Silver Oaks Dental Clinic has successfully performed thousands of root canal procedures, helping patients preserve their natural teeth and maintain optimal oral health. Our state-of-the-art facility in Durban utilises the latest endodontic technology and techniques to ensure comfortable, efficient treatment with excellent long-term outcomes.

Our team of qualified dental professionals is committed to providing personalised care and comprehensive treatment planning. We take the time to explain your options thoroughly, ensuring you feel confident in your treatment decisions.

To schedule a consultation and learn more about your root canal treatment options, contact Silver Oaks Dental Clinic at or call our friendly team today. Your oral health is our priority, and we’re here to help you make the best decisions for your smile.

Frequently Asked Questions About Root Canal Treatment

  1. How painful is a root canal procedure? Modern root canal treatment is typically no more uncomfortable than having a large filling. We use effective local anaesthesia and advanced pain management techniques to ensure your comfort throughout the procedure. Most patients experience minimal discomfort afterwards, which can be managed with over-the-counter pain relievers.
  2. How long does root canal treatment take? Most root canal procedures can be completed in one to two appointments, depending on the complexity of your case. Simple cases may take 60-90 minutes, whilst more complex treatments involving multiple roots may require additional time or visits.
  3. What is the success rate of root canal therapy? Root canal treatment has an excellent success rate of over 95%. With proper care and regular dental check-ups, most root canal-treated teeth can last a lifetime. The key to success is following post-treatment care instructions and maintaining good oral hygiene.
  4. Will I need a crown after root canal treatment? In most cases, yes. Root canal treatment removes the tooth’s nerve and blood supply, which can make the tooth more brittle over time. A crown provides essential protection and strength, significantly improving the long-term prognosis of the treated tooth.
  5. How much does root canal treatment cost compared to extraction and replacement? While root canal treatment may have a higher upfront cost than simple extraction, it’s typically more economical long-term. When you factor in the cost of replacing an extracted tooth with an implant, bridge, or partial denture, root canal therapy often proves to be the more cost-effective choice whilst preserving your natural tooth.